“Seiðman” Has Been Sent Back To The Editor

I just spent the week going through the first wave of edits on Seiðman, and it was pretty overwhelming.  I’d done a ton of research over the past three years and had it critiqued by people in Iceland and Norway, but I still kept finding things that I would have to jot down in a list of notes with a little question mark:

Did they use miles?  (No, they used the measurement mil, in some parts of Scandinavia, but I gather it was closer to a league, which is about 3.4 miles.)

Would Kol and Ari pass a bottle of ale back and forth?  (No, bottles weren’t common.  I went with a drinking skin, instead.)

Would they see stars in the sky, when they looked up?  This one turns out to be extremely tricky for those of us who don’t live near the arctic circle.  Not only does the sun set very late in summer, but it also doesn’t sink far below the horizon when it does.  This means that during certain months the sky never quite gets dark before the sun starts to rise again, so you wouldn’t see stars, if you looked up.

But the biggest anachronism I found was that I had described several sailing ships as having decks and forecastles.  This is absurd.  Viking longships had neither of these things.  I can’t believe I never noticed this before I submitted the novel, and none of my readers caught it either.  At least, I caught it before it went into publication.

There was also a passage I used from the Völuspa, one of the best-known Norse poems.  It was probably written before Norway and Iceland became fully Christian, though nobody knows for certain.  I quote two stanzas from it, and I was initially using the translation by Henry Adams Bellows.  Since he died in 1873, his translation would be out of copyright.  But a writer I know was recently accused of plagiarism for coincidental similarities between his novel and popular gay indie film, and I really don’t want to deal with someone claiming I “steal” from other sources.  So my wonderful husband came up with an original translation, based upon the Old Norse.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on ““Seiðman” Has Been Sent Back To The Editor

  1. That is so cool! I want you to know how much I appreciate when a writer does his or her homework on the topic they’re writing about.

    Perfect example of someone NOT doing their homework: a certain sparkly vampire series that my wife is gaga over. The story takes place in the Pacific Northwest (my home) and the characters call a lake in Seattle “Union Lake,” when anyone who lives here will tell you that the place is called “Lake Union.” And it’s not like Lake Union is a little pond or something. Nope, it’s right in the middle with some of the most prime real estate in the city on its shores. How did somebody not catch that?

  2. I don’t know. Even Google maps lists it as Lake Union. I use Google Maps a lot for stories at locations I can’t physically get to, but as I did with Seiðman, I try to find someone local to the area to go through and catch things like that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s